Pros and Cons of Knitting Vs Crochet

Knitting and crochet are often confused with each other, but they’re actually two completely different crafts that produce very different results. Both craft disciplines involve working with yarn to create fabric, but the process of making the loops is completely different.

In this article, we’ll discuss what makes knitting and crocheting different, as well as some differences in their pros and cons. We’ll also discuss how to choose the right for you.

Pros and Cons of Knitting Vs Crochet

Knitting vs. Crochet: How Can You Tell Them Apart

At first glance, it can be difficult to tell the difference between knitted and crocheted fabrics, since both are made with yarn, feature a variety of stitch patterns, and are equally warm. However, there are a few ways to tell them apart.

If you’ve ever wondered if a scarf, afghan or other item was knitted or crocheted, look at the stitches to find the answer. It’s usually fairly easy to tell knitting and crochet apart by looking at the stitches.

pros and cons knitting vs crochet

One way is to recognize the difference between the stitches. Look at the above image again.

The image above shows that the knitted garment on the left was done in stockinette stitch. While that of crochet was done in a double crochet stitch.

If you’re still not sure, look at the edge of work.

Knitting: The edges will look smooth (as in the knitting above) and there will typically be a little bit of a ridge on what is considered the wrong side of the work. This is because knitting always has two sides.

Crochet: The edges will look ragged with little loops sticking out from them (as in the crochet above). This is because crochet only has one side, which is usually considered the right side.

You could also recognize the differences in the stitches by noticing that crochet stitches are typically taller than knitting stitches, so crocheted fabric typically has larger holes.

Knitting vs Crochet: What Are the Similarities 

The first similarity between knitting and crochet is that both crafts require the use of a needle to make an item. 

Both of them also use yarn, thread, or some other type of fiber to make an item. 

In both knitting and crocheting, you can create nearly any type of fabric you want, from fine lace to thick, plush sweaters.

Another similarity between knitting and crocheting is that both are inexpensive to start as a beginner. 

Both have been found to have positive effects on mental health. 

They are portable activities that can be done anywhere from your favorite chair at home all the way up to an airplane.

Knitting Vs Crochet: Which Is Easier

With the popularity of knitting and crochet growing, people often ask the question: Which is easier?

There is no right answer, of course. “Easier” is a very subjective term. But we can look at facts to help make an informed decision.

In terms of a learning curve, crocheting is generally considered easier for most people because only one stitch is used. Knitting has a slightly steeper learning curve because there are multiple stitches used. But just like anything else in life, practice makes perfect! With either craft, you will get better with time and experience.

In terms of which craft is more popular, it depends on where you live in the world. In the US, crocheting has grown considerably in popularity over the last 5 years or so whereas knitting is relatively growing small. Looking at Google Trends might give us a hint as to why crocheting has gained so many new devotees recently. It takes less time to complete projects than knitting does.

Should I Knit or Crochet?

So, which one really is for you? Do you prefer knitting or crocheting?

In reality, though, the best thing for you to do is try both crafts out and see which one suits your needs best. It may come down to personal preference and what you’re better suited to rather than which craft is actually “better” in any objective sense.

Choose crochet if you…

  • Prefer the look of crochet pieces over knit
  • Are more comfortable using a single hook versus knitting needles
  • Have an easier time with the motion of crocheting
  • You like being able to create a project quickly
  • If you like being able to be more creative with your stitches

Choose knitting if you…

  • Prefer a clean, uniform look
  • Have a good sense of spatial awareness
  • Like the challenge of more complicated patterns
  • Like the look of finished knit pieces better than crochet
  • If you like being able to be more precise with your stitches
  • You prefer using two needles over one hook.

Pros and Cons Knitting Vs Crochet

Benefits of Knitting Over Crochet

Makes a finer fabric: Most knitters can create much tighter stitches than crocheters, so they can make finer fabrics that are ideal for things like socks or gloves. This can also be an advantage when making baby garments out of fingering-weight yarns that might be too fine for crochet hooks — but not for fine knitting needles.

Knitted fabric drapes well:  Which means it’s easy to make clothing such as pullovers and cardigans — especially when compared to crochet, which tends to be heavier and stiffer.

Knitting is easier to do without looking at your work:  Simply keep your eyes on the stitches on your needle rather than having to look back and forth between your stitches and your hook. While this isn’t necessarily true if you’re doing colorwork or lace.

Knitting Disadvantages

Knitting is harder to learn: It takes longer to get good at knitting than it does to get good at crochet. It can be frustrating to learn how to knit and if you want an easy start, you should probably learn crochet first.

You need more supplies: In crochet, you only need one needle (or hook) to do everything; with knitting, you have to have two needles (or more), plus stitch markers, safety pins, stitch holders, and other devices to hold stitches while you’re working with other stitches.

It’s harder to see your mistakes with knitting: In crochet, you can see which loops should be live on your hook at any given moment; in knitting, you have to keep track of where your yarnovers are as well as your knits and purl.

Knitting takes time and needs patience: Because with knitting you have to do some of the steps twice (knit the front and then knit the back), it takes more time than in crochet where you only have to pass through each stitch once. Knitting also requires more patience because of this extra step (which can be harder when making bigger projects).

Advantages of Crochet over Knitting

Crocheted fabric is more durable: Especially with larger stitches and heavier yarns.

Crocheted afghans are softer and more pliable than knitted blankets. The finished blanket will be lighter weight as well.

Crocheted fabric can be stretched into different shapes, making it great for bags, hats, and other wearable items that need to fit a wide range of shapes and sizes.

It’s easier to undo mistakes in crochet than in knitting. You can simply pull the hook out of the stitch, also known as frogging, then start over again.

Crochet stitch patterns are easy to learn because they are made out of only a few basic stitches, while knitting has many more stitch patterns.

Crocheting is easier for beginners than knitting because the basic stitch is simpler to learn.

Crochet Disadvantages

Crochet uses more yarn than knitting: If you’re trying to save money on yarn, knitting is better because it’s more efficient. Crochet stitches are larger than knitted ones and require more yarn, so it takes more to make the same garment.

Crochet is not recommended for making sweaters or socks: If you want to knit sweaters or socks, you can’t use a single piece of fabric — you need to shape the garment by adding increases and decreases. That’s much easier to do with knitting. 

Which is more relaxing knitting or crocheting?

Crocheting is a great stress reliever because it exercises both sides of the brain. 

Is it easier to teach a child to knit or crochet?

Some people say that it is easier to learn to knit, others say that it is easier to learn to crochet. Both knitting and crocheting can be a bit difficult for beginners, but the learning curve isn’t steep. Once you overcome that first few days when you struggle with your first stitches, you will glide through the rest of the project with ease.

Is crochet an expensive hobby?

Crochet isn’t necessarily expensive, but it can be. The crochet tools themselves are relatively inexpensive.

Why is knitting so hard?

While it’s not that hard, it requires practice—and that practice can be frustrating. It’s easy to make mistakes, but most mistakes are correctable. Some are challenging but correctable (like dropping a stitch), and some are so easy to fix that it’s almost ridiculous (like making a twisted stitch).

Is knitting an expensive hobby?

Whether knitting is expensive or not depends on what you are comparing it to, and what you are trying to make. Knitting can be as expensive as you want to make it. You could buy top-quality yarns and needles, but there are also some very good low-cost options available for beginners who want to try out the hobby without breaking the bank.

How long does it take to get good at crocheting?

It depends on how often you crochet and how much you want to learn. If you wanted to learn all the skills of crocheting, it could take a month of constant crocheting. If someone only crocheted for about two hours per week, it might take them as long as six months to become proficient at the basics.

Leave a Comment